| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Carnegie Mellon 21, Gettysburg 20 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| C | 4-1 | G34 | End of 2nd half, clock 00:00. |
| C | 3-6 | G39 | Pantalone, Phil rush for 5 yards to the GC34 (Kyle Luciano). |
| C | 2-8 | G41 | Sivek, Travis rush for 2 yards to the GC39 (Anthony Pastore). |
| C | 2-8 | G41 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 01:29. |
| C | 1-10 | G43 | Sivek, Travis rush for 2 yards to the GC41 (Tim Widdoes;Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 1-10 | G43 | CARNEGIE MELLON drive start at 01:35 (4th). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:34 |
| G | 4-7 | G43 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete. |
| G | 3-7 | G43 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Brian Betley (Scholl, Jon). |
| G | 3-7 | G43 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 01:48. |
| G | 2-10 | G40 | Tom Sturges rush for 3 yards to the GC43 (Crites, Clay;Tigay, Aleksey). |
| G | 1-10 | G40 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Alex Penta (McGovern, Steve). |
| G | 1-10 | G40 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 02:09 (4th). |
| | | Marks, Colin kickoff 59 yards to the GC11, Bryan DiSabato return 29 yards to the GC40 (Crites, Clay). |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 63 yards, TOP 05:04 |
| C | 1-G | C35 | CMU ball on CMU30. |
| | | Carnegie Mellon 21, Gettysburg 20 |
| | | Marks, Colin kick attempt good. |
| C | 4-G | G08 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Howe, Brendan for 8 yards to the GC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:09. |
| C | 3-G | G11 | Sivek, Travis rush for 3 yards to the GC8 (Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 2-G | G11 | Pantalone, Phil pass incomplete to Wisnieski, D. (Joe Anthes). |
| C | 1-G | G08 | Gimson, Robert rush for loss of 3 yards to the GC11 (Josh Jerrold;Tim Widdoes). |
| C | 1-G | G08 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 03:29. |
| C | 2-4 | G16 | Gimson, Robert rush for 8 yards to the GC8, 1ST DOWN CMU (Nick Duerr;Harold Barton). |
| C | 1-10 | G22 | Sivek, Travis rush for 6 yards to the GC16 (Nick Duerr;Harold Barton). |
| C | 1-10 | G32 | Gimson, Robert rush for 10 yards to the GC22, 1ST DOWN CMU (Harold Barton). |
| C | 4-1 | G37 | Gimson, Robert rush for 5 yards to the GC32, 1ST DOWN CMU (Joe Anthes). |
| C | 3-7 | G43 | Howe, Brendan pass complete to Howe, Brendan for 6 yards to the GC37 (Harold Barton). |
| C | 2-6 | G42 | Whitman, Colby rush for loss of 1 yard to the GC43 (Adam Fulmer). |
| C | 1-10 | G46 | Gimson, Robert rush for 4 yards to the GC42 (S. Sullivan;Nick Duerr). |
| C | 1-10 | C37 | Sivek, Travis rush for 17 yards to the GC46, 1ST DOWN CMU (Jason Taylor;S. Sullivan). |
| C | 1-10 | C37 | CARNEGIE MELLON drive start at 07:13 (4th). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:51 |
| G | 4-9 | G25 | Andrew Weingart punt 38 yards to the CMU37, downed. |
| G | 3-9 | G25 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to M. McInerney. |
| G | 2-10 | G24 | Ricky Manigat rush for 1 yard to the GC25 (Scholl, Jon). |
| G | 1-10 | G24 | Tom Sturges rush for no gain to the GC24 (Tigay, Aleksey;Crites, Clay). |
| G | 1-10 | G24 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 09:04 (4th). |
| | | Marks, Colin kickoff 61 yards to the GC9, Bryan DiSabato return 15 yards to the GC24 (Zacharias, S.). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 65 yards, TOP 02:38 |
| C | 1-G | C35 | CMU ball on CMU30. |
| | | Gettysburg 20, Carnegie Mellon 14 |
| | | Marks, Colin kick attempt good. |
| C | 2-3 | G05 | Pantalone, Phil rush for 5 yards to the GC0, 1ST DOWN CMU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:04. |
| C | 1-10 | G12 | Gimson, Robert rush for 7 yards to the GC5 (Adam Fulmer). |
| | | Wide out double pass |
| C | 1-10 | G36 | Howe, Brendan pass complete to Doo, Jeremy for 24 yards to the GC12, 1ST DOWN CMU (Nick Duerr). |
| C | 2-9 | G49 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Howe, Brendan for 13 yards to the GC36, 1ST DOWN CMU (Nick Duerr). |
| C | 1-10 | C50 | Whitman, Colby rush for 1 yard to the GC49 (Ali Hyali;Nick Duerr). |
| C | 2-10 | C35 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Howe, Brendan for 15 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN CMU (Adam Fulmer). |
| C | 1-10 | C35 | Gimson, Robert rush for no gain to the CMU35 (Jason Taylor). |
| C | 1-10 | C35 | CARNEGIE MELLON drive start at 11:42 (4th). |
| | | Andrew Weingart kickoff 53 yards to the CMU17, Rosenberry, J. return 18 yards to the CMU35 (David Gourley). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 50 yards, TOP 04:33 |
| G | 1-G | G35 | GC ball on GC30. |
| | | Gettysburg 20, Carnegie Mellon 7 |
| G | 4-G | C03 | Josh Huson field goal attempt from 20 GOOD, clock 11:42. |
| G | 4-G | C06 | PENALTY CMU offside defense 3 yards to the CMU3. |
| G | 3-G | C06 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to M. McInerney. |
| G | 2-G | C07 | Tom Sturges rush for 1 yard to the CMU6 (Kennedy, Sean;Sisson, Trent). |
| G | 1-G | C05 | Tom Sturges rush for loss of 2 yards to the CMU7 (Reggie, Mike). |
| G | 3-5 | C12 | Sean Incremona rush for 7 yards to the CMU5, 1ST DOWN GC (Kresge, Josh). |
| G | 2-7 | C14 | Tom Sturges rush for 2 yards to the CMU12 (Tigay, Aleksey;Crites, Clay). |
| G | 1-10 | C17 | Tom Sturges rush for 3 yards to the CMU14 (Scholl, Jon). |
| G | 1-10 | C17 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |