| C | 2-16 | C38 | End of 1st half, clock 00:00. |
| C | 1-10 | C44 | Pantalone, Phil sacked for loss of 6 yards to the CMU38 (Conor Quinn). |
| C | 1-10 | C44 | CARNEGIE MELLON drive start at 00:26 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 1 yards, TOP 02:25 |
| G | 4-22 | G30 | Andrew Weingart punt 33 yards to the CMU37, Kresge, Josh return 7 yards to the CMU44 (Hunter McMillan;David Rodriguez). |
| G | 4-22 | G30 | Timeout Carnegie Mellon, clock 00:38. |
| G | 3-12 | G40 | Matt Flynn sacked for loss of 10 yards to the GC30 (Sisson, Trent). |
| G | 3-7 | G45 | PENALTY GC false start 5 yards to the GC40. |
| G | 2-15 | G37 | Matt Flynn rush for 8 yards to the GC45 (Scholl, Jon). |
| G | 1-10 | G42 | Jamel Mutunga rush for loss of 5 yards to the GC37 (Tigay, Aleksey). |
| G | 2-4 | G35 | Jamel Mutunga rush for 7 yards to the GC42, 1ST DOWN GC (Bodnar, Jon;Falkenstein, D.). |
| G | 1-10 | G29 | Tom Sturges rush for 6 yards to the GC35 (Tigay, Aleksey). |
| G | 1-10 | G29 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 02:51 (2nd). |
| | | Marks, Colin kickoff 61 yards to the GC9, Bryan DiSabato return 20 yards to the GC29 (Luther, Chris). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 66 yards, TOP 03:57 |
| C | 1-G | C35 | CMU ball on CMU30. |
| | | Gettysburg 17, Carnegie Mellon 7 |
| | | Marks, Colin kick attempt good. |
| C | 2-G | G06 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Wisnieski, D. for 6 yards to the GC0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:51. |
| C | 1-G | G08 | Sivek, Travis rush for 2 yards to the GC6 (J. Holubowich). |
| C | 1-10 | G37 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Whitman, Colby for 29 yards to the GC8, 1ST DOWN CMU (Nick Duerr). |
| C | 3-3 | G43 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Doo, Jeremy for 6 yards to the GC37, 1ST DOWN CMU (Adam Fulmer). |
| C | 2-10 | C50 | Pantalone, Phil rush for 7 yards to the GC43 (Tim Widdoes). |
| C | 1-10 | C50 | Sivek, Travis rush for no gain to the 50 yardline (J. Holubowich;Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 3-5 | C39 | Pantalone, Phil pass complete to Doo, Jeremy for 11 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN CMU (Jason Taylor). |
| C | 2-9 | C35 | Gimson, Robert rush for 4 yards to the CMU39 (Josh Jerrold;Conor Quinn). |
| C | 1-10 | C34 | Sivek, Travis rush for 1 yard to the CMU35 (Anthony Pastore;Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 1-10 | C34 | CARNEGIE MELLON drive start at 06:48 (2nd). |
| | | Andrew Weingart kickoff 55 yards to the CMU15, Rosenberry, J. return 19 yards to the CMU34 (Tairi Mobley). |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 60 yards, TOP 03:37 |
| G | 1-G | G35 | GC ball on GC30. |
| | | Gettysburg 17, Carnegie Mellon 0 |
| | | Josh Huson kick attempt good. |
| G | 2-3 | C07 | Tom Sturges rush for 7 yards to the CMU0, 1ST DOWN GC, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:48. |
| G | 1-10 | C14 | Tom Sturges rush for 7 yards to the CMU7 (Bodnar, Jon). |
| G | 4-6 | C27 | Matt Flynn pass complete to Alex Penta for 13 yards to the CMU14, 1ST DOWN GC (McGovern, Steve). |
| G | 4-6 | C27 | Timeout Gettysburg, clock 07:49. |
| G | 3-6 | C27 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Ricky Manigat. |
| G | 2-10 | C31 | Tom Sturges rush for 4 yards to the CMU27 (Kresge, Josh;Falkenstein, D.). |
| G | 1-10 | C31 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Brian Betley. |
| | | Fake Punt |
| G | 4-1 | G49 | M. McInerney rush for 20 yards to the CMU31, 1ST DOWN GC (Cundiff, Jake). |
| G | 3-8 | G42 | Matt Flynn rush for 7 yards to the GC49 (Bodnar, Jon;Onyimba, Stan). |
| G | 2-8 | G42 | Matt Flynn pass incomplete to Alex Penta (Kresge, Josh). |
| G | 1-10 | G40 | Matt Flynn rush for 2 yards to the GC42 (Hauffe, Richard). |
| G | 1-10 | G40 | GETTYSBURG drive start at 10:25 (2nd). |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 37 yards, TOP 05:54 |
| C | 4-6 | G34 | Pantalone, Phil sacked for loss of 6 yards to the GC40 (Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 3-6 | G34 | Sivek, Travis rush for no gain to the GC34 (Jason Taylor;V. Ferrante). |
| C | 2-10 | G38 | Sivek, Travis rush for 4 yards to the GC34 (Harold Barton;Tim Widdoes). |
| C | 1-10 | G38 | Gimson, Robert rush for no gain to the GC38 (Jason Taylor;Joe Anthes). |
| C | 2-5 | G47 | Sivek, Travis rush for 9 yards to the GC38, 1ST DOWN CMU (Kyle Luciano). |
| C | 1-10 | C48 | Pantalone, Phil rush for 5 yards to the GC47 (Ali Hyali;Conor Quinn). |
| C | 4-14 | C33 | Adams, Matt punt 37 yards to the GC30, out-of-bounds, PENALTY GC personal foul 15 yards to the CMU48, 1ST DOWN CMU, NO PLAY. |
| C | 3-10 | C37 | Pantalone, Phil sacked for loss of 4 yards to the CMU33 (Conor Quinn). |
| C | 2-7 | C40 | Gimson, Robert rush for loss of 3 yards to the CMU37 (Josh Jerrold). |
| C | 2-7 | C40 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |